LP.ERB IS LP.PHINA'S DISCIPLE OR NOT???

copied from anyone conversation..........

hi Bro

thanks for yr reply~

and for yr info.~ listen my friend,

LP PHINA an apprentice come from HK in july~

thanks!

if you mean lp.erb wat nong moh kaeng

he did not learn wicha from lp.phina

the true story , lp.erb went to be his disciple

but you need to know background then

you will understand

in thai word , we have 3 word the same sound

"ข้า" (khaa) = I (me), servant or home mate

"ค่า" (khaa) = worth, value

"ฆ่า" (khaa) = murder

I DON'T KNOW WHEN LP.ERB WENT TO VISIT

WITH LP.PHINA BUT THE STORY IS TRUSTABLE

THEY MET TOGETHER AND LP.ERB ASKED

LP.PHINA TO BE HIS DISCIPLE

LP.PHINA SAID "IF YOU WANT TO LEARN WICHA ,

YOU NEED TO BE "KHA" FIRST.

IN THIS MEANING , LP.PHINA TOLD LP.ERB LIVED IN

WAT SANOMLAO AND DO THE JOB IN TEMPLE

THEN HE WILL TEACH HIM THE WICHA AND BE DISCIPLE

BUT LP.ERB THOUGH THAT "IF WANTED TO BE

LP.PHINA DISCIPLE FOR LEARN WICHA

NEED TO "KHAA" (MURDER) FIRST,

THEN LP,ERB GOT ANGRY THAT LP.PHINA TALKED

SO BAD , HOW COME HE CAN KILL MONK WHO HE

ASKED TO BE HIS MASTER THEN LP.ERB WALKED OUT

FROM WAT SANOMLAO . HE DID NOT LEARN ANYTHING

WITH LP.PHINA.

WE CAN DISCUSS LP.ERB IS DISCIPLE OR NOT ????

For my openion, LP.Erb is a very kind monk and he

is smart like to learn wicha from many great monks

as he knew, that is very good.

Wat Nong Moh Kaeng located in Chai Naat province

and its boarder is Uthai Thani where located Wat

Tha Koey then this is the cause the area of LP.Erb

and LP.Phina is closed , the story of this can be happened.

As we know from any magazine always talk about

LP.Erb's autobiography as he is LP.Phina's diciple

but there is no sources confirmed this quotation.

Or the story only pread after LP.Erb made the

stuff like Paladkig and Star look like LP.Phina's stuff.

Only for trading ???